Seniors Are Among the “Lazy and Dependent” Americans Mitt Romney Says Are “Not His Worry”
No doubt you’ve already seen the Mitt Romney video in which he describes to a group of $50,000 per plate donors his view of almost half of America’s population:
“There are
47 percent who are with him, (Obama) who are dependent upon government, who believe that they are victims, who believe the government has a responsibility to care for them, who believe that they are entitled to health care, to food, to housing, to you-name-it. That that’s an entitlement. And the government should give it to them. And they will vote for this president no matter what…These are people who pay no income tax. “[M]y job is not to worry about those people. I’ll never convince them they should take personal responsibility and care for their lives.” Mitt Romney, Florida Fundraising Event
While Governor Romney later described his comments as “not elegantly stated”, he stands by his basic point that nearly half of America see themselves victims and believe they are entitled to something. So where does this 47% come from? Romney’s comments are an odd amalgam of two reports: one on the number of Americans who don’t pay income taxes (not all taxes) and the other on the number of Americans who receive some form of government benefit including: retirees, college students, veterans and farmers – just to name a few. Together these two reports are used to bolster the often-expressed GOP view that America is a nation of “makers vs. takers”.
America’s retirees need to listen up…you are among the “takers” Mitt Romney criticizes as “dependent” because of your tax status and that you dare to receive the Social Security and Medicare benefits you’ve earned. Ezra Klein describes how seniors work into the Romney tax argument:
“The vast majority of households that don’t pay federal income taxes are either elderly or paying payroll taxes. As you can see below, 60 percent of those who don’t pay income tax are still working and paying taxes for Social Security and Medicare. Their tax liability is just too low to qualify for the income tax. Another 22 percent of non-payers are retirees. Only about 7.9 percent of households are not paying any federal taxes at all. That’s usually because they’re either unemployed or on disability or students or are very poor.”
So, targeted tax credits for the elderly puts retirees among the GOP “taker” class — regardless of the fact that most seniors paid a lifetime of income taxes while employed and continue to pay other taxes even into retirement. In addition, collecting the Social Security and Medicare benefits that you contributed to throughout your working lifetime also makes you “dependent” and “entitled” in the Romney/Ryan political perspective in which safety net programs are simply:
“…a hammock that lulls able-bodied people into lives of dependency and complacency, that drains them of their will and the intent to make the most of their lives.” Paul Ryan, March 2012
The Romney/Ryan economic strategy which claims our nation can’t afford tax cuts benefiting the poor and middle-class while at the same time proposing more tax cuts for the wealthy – to be paid for with benefit cuts for average Americans – has been laid out for all to see.
“Republicans have become outraged over the predictable effect of tax cuts they passed and are using that outrage as the justification for an agenda that further cuts taxes on the rich and pays for it by cutting social services for the non-rich. That’s why Romney’s theory here is more than merely impolitic. It’s actually core to his economic agenda.” Washington Post, Wonk Blog
“Romney’s message is that in order to lower taxes for his wealthy friends he will demand that retirees who worked hard, played by the rules, saved for retirement and counted on the promise of Social Security and Medicare, “take personal responsibility” and pay higher taxes, receive less in Social Security and trade in the promise of Medicare for Ryan’s Vouchercare, ending Medicare as we know it.” Daily Kos
Seniors need to ask themselves — Does this really sound like a President who will fight to preserve your economic security or your family’s? Because if you’re not Mitt Romney’s worry just 48 days before election day when will you be?
Social Security & Medicare Truth Tour Rolls thru Battleground States
Thanks to the many activists, volunteers and voters in Ohio and Virginia who turned out at the first events of our national “Truth Tour” this weekend. We’ve started collecting Pledge cards from voters nationwide who’ve committed to keeping candidates honest about their plans for the future of Social Security and Medicare — not just for current seniors but for all generations.
Jon Bauman, aka “Bowzer” from the group Sha Na Na, joined us in Ohio as he celebrated his 65th birthday by signing up for Medicare. He also urged seniors and their families to educate themselves about what their candidates for Congress and the White House really have planned for these vital programs.
This weekend is just the beginning. Keep in touch with the Truth Tour’s schedule here and plan on joining the campaign in person or lend your voice to the fight online.
National Truth Tour – Busting Social Security & Medicare Myths from Coast to Coast
As we prepare to kick off our national Truth Tour campaign tomorrow we thought we’d share this easy to understand (and share) infographic explaining just a few of the most commonly used myths by candidates in this 2012 campaign.
“Truth Campaign” on Social Security & Medicare Rolls Out this Week
We’re so
excited to announce today the kickoff of a new seven-figure national education campaign designed to educate and mobilize voters in key battleground states on the issues of Social Security and Medicare.
“This election will likely define the future of the nation’s social insurance safety net. The differences between most candidates in races from the White House to Congress on the future of Medicare, Social Security, and Medicaid are stark. However, those policy differences are often hidden behind poll-tested language in which “save” means slash and “protect” means privatize. It’s no wonder so many Americans, especially seniors, aren’t sure what to believe. The National Committee’s national Truth Tour is designed to provide all voters with the facts. There are differing plans for the future of these programs — which serve virtually every American family. Explaining how these plans could impact the middle-class is key to our voter education strategy.”…Max Richtman, NCPSSM President/CEO
We’ve talked here before about the GOP’s strategy to befuddle and confuse voters with a dodge and weave message on their plans for Medicare. The National Republican Congressional Committee ‘s tips for their candidates is pretty simple, don’t try to persuade voters that the Romney/Ryan plan is the right policy for Americans, instead simply pivot back to “Obamacare cuts Medicare” .
“Do not say: ‘entitlement reform,’ ‘privatization,’ ‘every option is on the table,’ … Do say: ‘strengthen,’ ‘secure,’ ‘save,’ ‘preserve, ‘protect.’” NRCC Medicare Memo
NCPSSM’s Truth Tour is one of the largest grassroots educational campaigns in our long history of defending Social Security and Medicare. It kicks off on Friday, September 14th with a National Pledge Day and launches in the key battleground states of Ohio and Virginia. National Committee Representatives in cities and towns across the country will stage rallies and activities to encourage voters to sign pledges promising to vote only for candidates who will preserve Social Security and Medicare benefits for current and future generations.
As the pledge drive continues throughout September and October, the campaign will also include voter education sessions led by local and nationally recognized experts, a six-figure paid media campaign including radio, on-line and mobile billboard advertising, door-to-door canvassing, new national polling, tele-town halls, social media outreach and an expanded grassroots field operation.
Live in Ohio or Virginia? Join Us at These Kickoff events
Ohio, September 14-15: Entertainer Jon Bauman, best know as “Bowzer” of the group Sha Na Na, turns 65 on September 14th. He’ll mark his birthday by enrolling in Medicare and urging Ohioans to get the truth about candidates’ plans for the future of vital programs serving millions of American retirees. The Truth Tour mobile billboard truck will also be on hand as Bauman visits Ohio events in Marietta and Canton on September 14th with additional stops in Cincinnati, Dayton, and Toledo on September 15th. The full schedule is available at TheTruthNow.org.
Virginia, September 14: NCPSSM President/CEO, Max Richtman, will join Virginia seniors at a National Pledge Day event in Richmond urging Virginians to make it clear to candidates that Medicare and Social Security benefits are vital to the future of generations of Americans. Details are here.
Get Involved – Wherever You Live
We hope our National Committee members and supporters will join us at any Truth Tour event that comes to your town. But even if you can’t — there are a number of ways you can still make your voice heard.
Seniors Are Among the “Lazy and Dependent” Americans Mitt Romney Says Are “Not His Worry”
No doubt you’ve already seen the Mitt Romney video in which he describes to a group of $50,000 per plate donors his view of almost half of America’s population:
“There are
While Governor Romney later described his comments as “not elegantly stated”, he stands by his basic point that nearly half of America see themselves victims and believe they are entitled to something. So where does this 47% come from? Romney’s comments are an odd amalgam of two reports: one on the number of Americans who don’t pay income taxes (not all taxes) and the other on the number of Americans who receive some form of government benefit including: retirees, college students, veterans and farmers – just to name a few. Together these two reports are used to bolster the often-expressed GOP view that America is a nation of “makers vs. takers”.
America’s retirees need to listen up…you are among the “takers” Mitt Romney criticizes as “dependent” because of your tax status and that you dare to receive the Social Security and Medicare benefits you’ve earned. Ezra Klein describes how seniors work into the Romney tax argument:
“The vast majority of households that don’t pay federal income taxes are either elderly or paying payroll taxes. As you can see below, 60 percent of those who don’t pay income tax are still working and paying taxes for Social Security and Medicare. Their tax liability is just too low to qualify for the income tax. Another 22 percent of non-payers are retirees. Only about 7.9 percent of households are not paying any federal taxes at all. That’s usually because they’re either unemployed or on disability or students or are very poor.”
So, targeted tax credits for the elderly puts retirees among the GOP “taker” class — regardless of the fact that most seniors paid a lifetime of income taxes while employed and continue to pay other taxes even into retirement. In addition, collecting the Social Security and Medicare benefits that you contributed to throughout your working lifetime also makes you “dependent” and “entitled” in the Romney/Ryan political perspective in which safety net programs are simply:
“…a hammock that lulls able-bodied people into lives of dependency and complacency, that drains them of their will and the intent to make the most of their lives.” Paul Ryan, March 2012
The Romney/Ryan economic strategy which claims our nation can’t afford tax cuts benefiting the poor and middle-class while at the same time proposing more tax cuts for the wealthy – to be paid for with benefit cuts for average Americans – has been laid out for all to see.
“Republicans have become outraged over the predictable effect of tax cuts they passed and are using that outrage as the justification for an agenda that further cuts taxes on the rich and pays for it by cutting social services for the non-rich. That’s why Romney’s theory here is more than merely impolitic. It’s actually core to his economic agenda.” Washington Post, Wonk Blog
“Romney’s message is that in order to lower taxes for his wealthy friends he will demand that retirees who worked hard, played by the rules, saved for retirement and counted on the promise of Social Security and Medicare, “take personal responsibility” and pay higher taxes, receive less in Social Security and trade in the promise of Medicare for Ryan’s Vouchercare, ending Medicare as we know it.” Daily Kos
Seniors need to ask themselves — Does this really sound like a President who will fight to preserve your economic security or your family’s? Because if you’re not Mitt Romney’s worry just 48 days before election day when will you be?
Social Security & Medicare Truth Tour Rolls thru Battleground States
Thanks to the many activists, volunteers and voters in Ohio and Virginia who turned out at the first events of our national “Truth Tour” this weekend. We’ve started collecting Pledge cards from voters nationwide who’ve committed to keeping candidates honest about their plans for the future of Social Security and Medicare — not just for current seniors but for all generations.
Jon Bauman, aka “Bowzer” from the group Sha Na Na, joined us in Ohio as he celebrated his 65th birthday by signing up for Medicare. He also urged seniors and their families to educate themselves about what their candidates for Congress and the White House really have planned for these vital programs.
This weekend is just the beginning. Keep in touch with the Truth Tour’s schedule here and plan on joining the campaign in person or lend your voice to the fight online.
National Truth Tour – Busting Social Security & Medicare Myths from Coast to Coast
As we prepare to kick off our national Truth Tour campaign tomorrow we thought we’d share this easy to understand (and share) infographic explaining just a few of the most commonly used myths by candidates in this 2012 campaign.
“Truth Campaign” on Social Security & Medicare Rolls Out this Week
We’re so excited to announce today the kickoff of a new seven-figure national education campaign designed to educate and mobilize voters in key battleground states on the issues of Social Security and Medicare.
“This election will likely define the future of the nation’s social insurance safety net. The differences between most candidates in races from the White House to Congress on the future of Medicare, Social Security, and Medicaid are stark. However, those policy differences are often hidden behind poll-tested language in which “save” means slash and “protect” means privatize. It’s no wonder so many Americans, especially seniors, aren’t sure what to believe. The National Committee’s national Truth Tour is designed to provide all voters with the facts. There are differing plans for the future of these programs — which serve virtually every American family. Explaining how these plans could impact the middle-class is key to our voter education strategy.”…Max Richtman, NCPSSM President/CEO
We’ve talked here before about the GOP’s strategy to befuddle and confuse voters with a dodge and weave message on their plans for Medicare. The National Republican Congressional Committee ‘s tips for their candidates is pretty simple, don’t try to persuade voters that the Romney/Ryan plan is the right policy for Americans, instead simply pivot back to “Obamacare cuts Medicare” .
“Do not say: ‘entitlement reform,’ ‘privatization,’ ‘every option is on the table,’ … Do say: ‘strengthen,’ ‘secure,’ ‘save,’ ‘preserve, ‘protect.’” NRCC Medicare Memo
NCPSSM’s Truth Tour is one of the largest grassroots educational campaigns in our long history of defending Social Security and Medicare. It kicks off on Friday, September 14th with a National Pledge Day and launches in the key battleground states of Ohio and Virginia. National Committee Representatives in cities and towns across the country will stage rallies and activities to encourage voters to sign pledges promising to vote only for candidates who will preserve Social Security and Medicare benefits for current and future generations.
As the pledge drive continues throughout September and October, the campaign will also include voter education sessions led by local and nationally recognized experts, a six-figure paid media campaign including radio, on-line and mobile billboard advertising, door-to-door canvassing, new national polling, tele-town halls, social media outreach and an expanded grassroots field operation.
Live in Ohio or Virginia? Join Us at These Kickoff events
Ohio, September 14-15: Entertainer Jon Bauman, best know as “Bowzer” of the group Sha Na Na, turns 65 on September 14th. He’ll mark his birthday by enrolling in Medicare and urging Ohioans to get the truth about candidates’ plans for the future of vital programs serving millions of American retirees. The Truth Tour mobile billboard truck will also be on hand as Bauman visits Ohio events in Marietta and Canton on September 14th with additional stops in Cincinnati, Dayton, and Toledo on September 15th. The full schedule is available at TheTruthNow.org.
Virginia, September 14: NCPSSM President/CEO, Max Richtman, will join Virginia seniors at a National Pledge Day event in Richmond urging Virginians to make it clear to candidates that Medicare and Social Security benefits are vital to the future of generations of Americans. Details are here.
Get Involved – Wherever You Live
We hope our National Committee members and supporters will join us at any Truth Tour event that comes to your town. But even if you can’t — there are a number of ways you can still make your voice heard.