Font Size

Senator Corker Says Medicare and Social Security are “Generational Theft”

5/27/2011 6:57 AM   By NCPSSM
The new GOP Medicare Strategy these days appears to be if you don’t like the message just shoot the messenger.   Yesterday’s Senate Aging Committee hearing provided one glimpse into this approach. NCPSSM Executive VP/Acting CEO and LCAO Chair, Max Richtman , testified yesterday before the Senate Select Committee on Aging about  Older Americans Act programs, like home healthcare, Meals on Wheels, long term care ombudsman and many others.   However, rather than talking about these vital programs, ranking GOP member Sen. Bob Corker was much more interested in attacking seniors organizations like ours for not supporting his legislation setting a Medicare Kill Switch with arbitrary spending caps, or the GOP/Ryan Budget bill which Senator Corker voted for or even means-testing the programs, turning them into welfare programs. Attacking seniors’ organizations for representing their members is nothing new. Fiscal commission co-chair, Alan Simpson, has made a career of it.   However, it’s clear GOP members in Washington are feeling the heat from their constituents, young and old alike, who do not support destroying Social Security or Medicare under the guise of deficit reduction. Starting with raucous town halls nationwide this spring followed by the election of a pro-Medicare Democrat in one of the reddest Congressional Districts in New York, it’s clear the American people understand the GOP/Ryan Budget plan would destroy Medicare and they don’t like it, period. That’s a message no amount of spin will fix and no amount of name-calling will change.
CATEGORY: [entitlement reform], [healthcare], [Medicare]


Comments

Got something to say? Join the discussion »
  1. bvongrabe's avatar bvongrabe said on 6/27/2012 6:16 PM: Reply  
    Social Security and Medicare are insurance plans into which generations have paid their premiums. Indeed, tax payers paid $2.5 TRILLIONS into the trust fund, from where the money was used by about every president since Reagan for other pruposes, including by Bush to pay for a war that was commenced under fraudulent pretense ! Now Republicans want to kill S.S. and Medicare so they don't have to pay back the money they took out of the trust fund ! That is true THEFT ON GENERATIONS orchestrated by the Republicans ! Only a complete idiot can vote for Reps !
  2. Dan Heffner's avatar Dan Heffner said on 6/27/2012 6:16 PM: Reply  
    Social Security is not generational theft. Congressional thieves that raided the Social Security Fund with no intentions of paying back is a big problem. Where do they get off at stealing our money, yes stealing when they don't get our OK? They have no business or right to take our Social Security Funds. I say Congress should have to pay their entire saleries back into the Social Security Fund until it is all paid back. Just like above, as for Medicare, he doesn't know what he is talking about. Vote him out at election time!
  3. Shirley's avatar Shirley said on 6/27/2012 6:16 PM: Reply  
    Republican leaders in Congress would have us believe that most Americans support cutting Social Security and Medicare payments as a way to cut the federal budget deficit. But don't you believe it. As the AFL-CIO and other labor sources have discovered, that's at best a figment of the Republican imagination. Or, as is most likely, it's a bald-faced political lie. The proof came in a poll marking the 75th anniversary of Social Security this year. It was conducted by a prominent research organization, Greenberg Quilan Rosner, and commissioned by the nation's leading public employee unions, the Service Employees International and American Federation of State, County and Municipal Employees, joined by MoveOn.org and the Campaign for America's Future. The poll was in response to Republican House leader John Boehner's call for reducing the federal budget deficit by raising the Social Security retirement age to 70, while continuing President Bush's massive tax breaks for multi-billion-dollar corporations and wealthy individuals. Boehner, that is, wants to lower the Republicans' rich friends' taxes at the expense of Americans who must rely on Social Security payments, averaging less than $14,000 a year, to meet their basic living expenses. It would make much more sense, of course, to reduce the deficit by increasing taxes on the wealthy at least to the level they were before Bush's tax cuts, rather than do it by raising the retirement age and making other financial cutbacks that hurt low and middle income Americans. So, what did the poll show? Most Democrats and independents responding wanted to end the Bush tax cuts that, if not repealed, will increase the deficit by an estimated $3.1 trillion over the next decade and reduce government revenue by more than $650 billion. That obviously would greatly curtail Social Security and other government programs for poor and middle class Americans. It shouldn't surprise anyone that most of the Republicans polled did not want to repeal the tax cuts and thus help government provide more services to those who need them, often badly need them. Nevertheless, nearly 70 percent of the probable voters polled, whatever their political party, opposed cutting Social Security and Medicare to reduce the deficit. What’s more, two-thirds of the Republicans also opposed raising the retirement age, despite their general dislike of the Social Security system. Raising the retirement age from 67 to 70 obviously would greatly curtail Social Security and other government programs designed to help poor and middle class Americans. But that apparently didn't disturb many of the Republicans polled. Most of them did not want to repeal the tax cuts under any circumstance. The AFL-CIO concluded - and quite accurately, I think - that "those conservative politicians who want to use concern about deficits as an opening to go after Social Security or Medicare risk a backlash" from voters. The poll made clear that relatively few people are buying the Republican claims that Social Security and Medicare outlays are a major cause of the continuing federal budget deficit. Too many people have too much sense to believe that. But what did sensible voters see as the main causes of the deficit? Nearly half of those polled blamed the costs of the wars in Iraq and Afghanistan. About a third blamed the bailouts of big banks and the auto industry. Nearly a third blamed lobbyists and special interests for getting unnecessary spending put into the budget. Almost as many placed the major blame on President Obama's economic recovery or stimulus plan. About one-fourth blamed the Bush tax cuts. A relative few blamed the economic recession that reduced tax revenue and required costly government support for the unemployed. A relatively few others blamed the deficit on the cost of Medicare prescription drug benefits. What it boils down to is this, as the AFL-CIO's James Parks said in a bit of public advice to GOP Congressman Boehner: "The public doesn't like your plan to cut their Social Security so your rich friends can get another tax break." Anyone doubting the popularity and importance of Social Security need only consider a recent AARP survey that showed "exceedingly high" support for the program. " Clearly," said AARP researcher Colette Thayer, " most Americans rely on Social Security and expect it to be a source of income in their retirement. In fact, it is the most commonly cited source of retirement income." Whatever their ages, whether over 30 or under, the poll - just as others like taken on the program's anniversary dates five, 15 and 25 years ago - shows that Social Security is one of the government's most important programs in that it provides essential retirement income to millions of Americans who would otherwise have little or no income. The Campaign for America's Future and MoveOn.org, will be jointly campaigning for candidates in the coming midterm elections who'll pledge to block cuts in Social Security and Medicare and otherwise back the organizations' liberal agendas. The unions that helped them sponsor the poll will also be waging major campaigns, as will other AFL-CIO affiliates. They're backing the kind of political candidates we should all back – and as strongly as we can. Our social security depends on it.
  4. godi38's avatar godi38 said on 6/27/2012 6:16 PM: Reply  
    I do not understand that a congressional man who should protect all citizen interest speaks about "generational theft" when we want to protect Medicare and Social Security. Who is this ignorant of to insult my opinion about human moral and necessity? Who put this trash to represent America interest?
  5. Carol W's avatar Carol W said on 6/27/2012 6:16 PM: Reply  
    What is wrong with these people? Aren't they the ones who keep saying they are Christians, yet they continue to attack the senior citizens for justly collecting pensions, social security, and Medicare. These people need to get their act together and take it out on some other road.
  6. Classof65's avatar Classof65 said on 6/27/2012 6:16 PM: Reply  
    I received an email from Senator Corker today in response to an email I sent him about keeping his hands off my Social Security and Medicare. Now, this guy doesn't know me from Adam, but he's pretty sure I didn't vote him into office since I'm a registered Dem. So he really doesn't care what I think. The tone of his email is that he's definitely smarter and richer than I am, since he's a Senator and I'm not, and that he therefore should decide what's best for all of us -- despite the fact that I am allowed to vote once in a while. So, basically, he's going to vote to do "something" to these entitlement programs and we should all feel appreciative that he would even condescend to let his computer talk to my computer.... I hope he doesn't get too comfortable in Washington. If he continues to meddle with SS/M, he might not be there too long... I hope.

Post A Comment

 [Quick Submit with Ctrl+Enter]

Remember my details
Notify me of followup comments via e-mail

Get the Latest

Indicates required fields


Questions?

Have a Social Security or Medicare question?


 

 

Media Contacts

Pamela Causey
Communications Director
Causeyp@ncpssm.org(202) 216-8378
(202) 236-2123 cell

Kim Wright
Assistant Director of Communications
Wrightk@ncpssm.org
(202) 216-8414

Entitled to Know

     

 

Copyright © 2012 by NCPSSM
Login  |